Yugoslavia icty announced a new rule of icl rejecting duress as a complete defense to. Excuses, justifications, and duress at the international. Duress is not a defense to an intentional murder of an innocent person, but could, under circumstances where all elements of duress are present, mitigate the crime of murder to voluntary manslaughter. Mcdermott with reference to case law discuss the concept of duress in contract law. The relationship between international humanitarian law and the. Commonwealth and international perspectives on self defence, duress and necessity stanley yeo abstract this article compares the provisions on selfddence, duress and necessity contained in the criminal code 1995 cth and the statute of the international criminal court the rome statute.
Selfdefence is a full defence in criminal law to many crimes including murder, and a defendant may defend himself or another. This paper has shown that the minoritys approach is preferable as it is appropriate for international criminal law, the nature of duress, and is supported by subsequent developments. From nuremberg to article 311 d of the rome statute of the international criminal court. The husband drafted a marital settlement agreement which gave his wife only 1015% of the marital community. Selfdefence is a common law defence, but is has been clarified by section 3 of the criminal law act 1967. Victimperpetrators and individual criminal responsibility in international criminal law. This article argues that in the context of international criminal law, the defence of duress must be considered where an actor is compelled to commit a crime as a result of a sufficiently serious threat even if the form of that threat is not explicit or direct and the pending harm will not necessarily occur within a specific period of time. It has been established that duress is available to all crimes, except murder, attempted murder, and certain forms of treason. The notion of duress must be distinguished both from undue influence in the civ. No duress howovor was found to be prcsont in thin casc. Commonwealth and international perspectives on self defence. Duress, international criminal law and literature by illan.
Duress, international criminal law and literature, journal. A second group of papers studies the sensitivity of crime to changes in the severity of criminal sanctions. But a threat of harm at a future time does not support the mitigation defense of duress. The author notes that case law and the legal literature have never clarified the content of. This approach to the issue of consent is seen as just the mirror image of the definition. An actual or a threatened violence or restraint of a mans person, contrary to law, to compel him to enter into a contract, or to discharge one. Request pdf duress as a defence under international criminal law this chapter begins with an examination of the concept of defences in international criminal law before retracing the. From nuremberg to the international criminal court, finding.
Nonetheless, many child soldiers would still find it difficult to raise duress as a complete defence due to the application of the strict criteria of duress under international criminal law. An introduction to international criminal law and procedure. What type of justification or excuse might a defendant bring to trial to explain his or her behavior or involvement in the alleged crime. Reconstitutionalizing duress and necessity ssrn papers.
He is the editorinchief of the second edition of the encyclopedia of crime and justice and the author of two treatises and two casebooks in the fields of criminal law and procedure and numerous articles on criminal responsibility. In august of 2009, dr sherif abdelfattah was issued with a ticket after he was caught breaking the speed limit in a bid to reach a woman who was severely bleeding. The prosecution of children for international crimes often focuses only on whether children can and should be prosecuted under international. Introduction to international criminal law coursera. The leasing case establishing that duress is not a defence to murder is r v howe 1987.
Mar 22, 2021 free pdf download child soldiers and the defence of duress under international criminal law this book examines the use of coercion as a defense in international criminal law, especially in the case of child soldiers. Duress is pressure exerted upon a person to coerce that person to perform an act they ordinarily would not perform. Sep 01, 2006 one should distinguish between causal, moral and criminal responsibility. Alleged errors relating to ndahlmanassuperior responsibility prosecution ground 5 71 case no, ictr0168a 16 december 20. By a majority of three to two the house of lords in r v gotts 1992 decided that duress was not a defence to attempted murder. Essays on law and morality oxford clarendon, 1979, 210229.
Affirmative defenses in international criminal proceedings chapter. Duress as a defence under international criminal law. Pdf the defence of duress in international criminal law. The most significant aspect of the icc definition of duress is that it is a proportionate defense. Duress as an excuse defence for international crimes. Criminal court on superior orders by comparing it with customary international law. Duress of circumstances is a recognition in english law that sometimes it is necessary to commit a crime in order to avoid a greater evil. Duress by threatened breach of contract mcgill law journal. Duress per minas or compulsion by threats has not been frequently invoked as a defense in criminal cases and, as a consequence, the law concerning it is both meagre and uncertain. Responsibility for participation in a joint criminal enterprise 64 3. Duress, international criminal law and literature journal. A further anomaly in the existing law is the fact that while provocation is recognised as a valid defence because the defendant has been caused to lose control and should not in principle therefore held to be accountable for his actions, he will nonetheless remain subject to criminal liability and sanctions as a result of the mandatory. Oct 23, 2016 although some forms of duress may be challenging to prove in a court of law, the use of physical force, or believable threat of physical harm, if proven, quickly results in nullification of the contract. Heim, the applicability of the duress defense to the killing of innocent persons by civilians.
Duress, international criminal law and literature, journal of. A perspective on the rome statutes defence of duress. The case law database cld is a gateway to the jurisprudence of the ictr, icty, and irmct appeals chambers it provides direct access to extracts of key judgements and decisions rendered by the ictr, icty, and irmct appeals chambers since their inception, as well as to fulltext versions of the corresponding appeal judgements and decisions. Strong chair in law at ohio state university, michael e. This paper aims to show that international criminal law should not necessarily follow domestic criminal law doctrines. Duress is most often, however, understood in terms of one or the other of the surrounding categories, thus being thought to be either a justification or a denial of the voluntariness of the agents conduct. Elements of duress, necessity and provocation law teacher. The doctrine arises not only in criminal law but also in civil law, where it is relevant to contract law and trusts law. Justia california criminal jury instructions calcrim 2020 3402. This literature assesses the responsiveness of crime to sentence. Feb 15, 2018 the concept of duress encapsulated in article 311d of the rome statute of the international criminal court is a novel inclusion in a statute created to allow prosecution of serious crimes against the person in international criminal law. The latest versions of adobe reader do not support v. An analysis of duress in international criminal law. Duress primary tabs when a person makes unlawful threats or otherwise engages in coercive behavior that cause another person to commit acts that the other person would otherwise not commit.
The doctrine of economic duress has also been applied in the family law context. Most jurisdictions require that the source of the threat be another person. Although the international criminal court icc has been mostly hailed as a victory, islamic states still regard its application of international criminal law norms with scepticism. While the case of erdemovic has done much to substantiate the existence of the defence of duress at international law it appears to have. Victimperpetrator as a mitigating factor in establishing criminal responsibility 42. Criminal law a505 a spring 2003 day 37 duress and insanity. In jurisprudence, duress or coercion refers to a situation whereby a person performs an act as a result of violence, threat, or other pressure against the person. Reconstitutionalizing duress and necessity tspace university. Duress has been described as the pressure of a big stick or the bottom line. The paper focuses on whether duress should be a defence to crimes against humanity when it involves killing the innocent, an issue dealt with by the icty in the erdemovic case. From nuremberg to the international criminal court. Pdf islamic law sharia and the jurisdiction of the. Part iii proposes a revised definition of duress for the icc to adopt that would rest. The case of dominic ongwen before the international criminal court.
A the former chairman of a company threatened b the managing director with death if he did not agree to purchase as shares in the company. The academic literature notes the increasing signi. From nuremberg to the international criminal court, finding the balance between justification and excuse, leiden journal of international law, 28 2015, pp. This module includes a primer on international law that will introduce students with limited backgrounds on international law to the basic foundations of the field. The processes of expansion are themselves of interest, as illustrating methods of growth in a system of case law. Duress of imprisonment, where a man actually loses his liberty. Sir william blackstone divides duress into two sorts. The fundamental concept of crime in international criminal law. If a man who commits a crime, not by the action of his free will, is to be found guilty, we are essentially equating causal responsibility with criminal guilt. Thus, some degree of culpability already attaches to the defendant for what was done in criminal law, the defendants motive for breaking the law is generally irrelevant. Excuses, justifications, and duress at the international criminal tribunals noam wiener abstract this article examines the application of the defense of duress by international criminal tribunals through analyzing opposing theoretical approaches to justifications and excuses. The pluralism of international criminal law digital repository.
Conclusionthe availability of duress in international criminal law raises difficult moral and legal questions. Dawson t the boundaries of common law duress have been gradually expanding for more than a century. One should distinguish between causal, moral and criminal responsibility. This logic clearly does not correspond with that of the rest of international criminal law. Duress as a defence under international criminal law request pdf. But the consent 0 in conarla, tho ontario court of appeal a penre to consider thet tho 6nme rule applios to common law duress. The failure of the iccs article 31 duress definition. The defence of superior orders european journal of international. Duress 57 a alleged failure to raise duress as a special defence 58 b assessment ofthe evidence 60 2.
Individual criminal responsibility in international. It was established on 20 october 1975, pursuant to section 3 f thelaw reform o commission act 1975. It should not set intractable standards of behaviour which require mankind to perform acts of martyrdom, and brand as criminal any behaviour falling below those standards. Defenses and punishments lesson 4 overview this lesson discusses what happens after a crime is committed. Chapter 1s emphasis is on the definition of duress and necessity. From sophocles theban plays a form of dialectic on the nature of guilt to the erdemovic judgment perhaps the most holistic jurisprudential work on. Blacks law dictionary defines duress as any unlawful threat or coercion used. A comment on the defence of duress in international criminal law. The defence of duress in international law, examined through the lens of philosophy and literature, provides a fascinating exposition of the modern relationship between law and morality. Victimperpetrators, a new kind of evil in international criminal law 38 3. As this book deals with crimes committed by child soldiers, it does not matter in. Lv march 2017 police manpower or policing intensity.
A defendant who raises a defense of duress has actually done everything to constitute the actus reus of the crime, and has the mens rea because they intended to do it to avoid some threatened or actual harm. Defense perspectives on international criminal justice april 2017. This lesson also includes a video lecture and readings that outline the brief history of international criminal law starting with the nuremberg trials. Introductionthe erdemovic case called upon the icty appeals chamber to determine whether duress could be a complete defence to international crimes. Sep 01, 2006 duress, international criminal law and literature duress, international criminal law and literature wall, illan rua 20060901 00. Availability of duress and fraud upon the principal as. Excuses, justifications, and duress at the international criminal. The defense of duress under international criminal law, a defendant can raise an affirmative defense of duress when the person, faced with an imminent danger to life, 10. Both defenses fail if the defendant had a reasonable alternative to violating the law.
Therefore, even if interpreted in a different light, duress is not the ultimate defence as so often claimed by legal scholars. This is an extract of our compulsion and duress document, which we sell as part of our laws201 criminal law notes collection written by the top tier of univerity of otago students. Limits of, and exclusions from, the defence of duress. The following is a more accessble plain text extract of the pdf sample above, taken from our laws201 criminal law notes. The commissions second programme for law reform, prepared in consultation. It may also result in criminal charges against the perpetrator. An introduction to international criminal law and procedure this marketleading textbook gives an authoritative account of international criminal law, and focuses on what the student needs to know the crimes that are dealt with by international courts and tribunals as well as the procedures that police the investigation and. This article argues that in the context of international criminal law, the defence of duress must be considered where an actor is compelled to commit a crime as a result of a sufficiently serious. Duress or threats free legal information laws, blogs, legal services and more. Commonwealth and international perspectives on self. Duress in english law is a complete common law defence, operating in favour of those who commit crimes because they are forced or compelled to do so by the circumstances, or the threats of another. Furthermore, the case law of the international criminal tribunals offers little assistance on this matter. The prosecution of children for international crimes often only focuses on whether children can and should be prosecuted under international law. Given that the definition of a mental element varies upon each criminal.
From sophocles theban plays a form of dialectic on the nature of guilt to the erdemovic judgment perhaps the most holistic jurisprudential work on duress, i hope to trace the now blurred line between moral and legal punishment. Excusing the unjustifiable introduction law is based on what society can reasonably expect of its members. This chapter begins with an examination of the concept of defences in international criminal law before retracing the development and the application of the defence of duress in national and international law. Request pdf duress as a defence under international criminal law this chapter begins with an examination of the concept of defences in international. The leasing case establishing that duress is not a defence to murder is r v howe 1987 by a majority of three to two the house of lords in r v gotts 1992 decided that duress was not a defence to attempted murder. A comment on the defence of duress in international criminal law 2014 14. This book investigates the use of duress as a defence in international criminal law, specifically in cases of child soldiers. Duress, coercion, and entrapment notes digestible notes. Child soldiers and the defence of duress under international. The applicability of the duress defense to the killing of. It is invoked by a party who claims that he was forced into entering the contract or modifying a term in the contract contract law, paul a. Courts typically explain necessity, on the other hand, as a choice between two evils. Defences duress and necessity the crown prosecution service. Duress, on the one hand, arises from the actions of other peoplethe classic example is one person forcing another to commit a crime at gunpoint.
695 1172 290 573 1028 778 1555 1023 1387 416 712 924 1419 381 578 747 230 1632 835 1054 1296 682 239 1050 1354 1442 1701 418 859 542 413